When it comes to hiring in the engineering industry, a common debate arises: Who is the better choice of hire, the university graduate with an engineering degree, or the graduate apprentice with years of real-life application under their belt? This is a frequent conversation we have with clients and industry professionals, and it’s a subjective one with no definitive answer. Nevertheless, let’s break it down so you can decide for yourself.
Some Key Strengths of Graduate Apprentices
Real-Life Experience: The value of real-life experience in an apprenticeship cannot be understated. Employers frequently emphasise how crucial this is, as it prepares apprentices for the practical demands of the job. They’ve been in real-world situations, solving actual problems and facing day-to-day challenges that a purely academic setting can’t replicate. Apprentices learn to tackle unexpected challenges and step out of their comfort zones. This practical knowledge can make apprentices very effective employees.
Workplace Dynamics: Apprentices are used to navigating working relationships and understanding workplace dynamics. They’ve learned to communicate, collaborate, and function effectively within a team, which can be a significant advantage and make them an easier fit into the company culture.
Nationally Recognised Qualification: Apprentices come with a qualification that is recognised nationwide, ensuring a standard level of competency. This certification validates their skills and knowledge, providing a reliable benchmark for employers.
Work Ethic: Having worked throughout their apprenticeship, these individuals often have a strong work ethic and are open to continuous learning. They understand the importance of dedication, hard work, and the need to constantly improve their skills. They also come with a professional mindset, meaning they understand the importance of company culture, meeting deadlines, and functioning effectively within a team, so they won’t require additional training in workplace expectations.
Some Key Strengths of University Graduates
Cutting-Edge Knowledge: University graduates come equipped with the latest theoretical knowledge and practical skills from rigorous academic training. They are up to date with the newest industry trends, technologies, and methodologies. This knowledge can be particularly valuable for companies looking to modernise their existing work practices.
Fresh Perspectives and Creativity: These graduates often bring innovative ideas and creative problem-solving approaches. Their fresh perspectives can help unlock new potential and drive company success. They may challenge existing processes and introduce new ways of thinking that can lead to significant improvements, although this may only prove valuable to companies open to change.
Technological Fluency: The digital revolution has transformed the engineering landscape, requiring adaptability and technological fluency. University graduates are proficient with the latest software tools, automation technologies, and digital platforms, which can help streamline processes and enhance productivity. Their familiarity with emerging technologies ensures that they can contribute to modernising and future-proofing the company.
Strategic Talent Development: Recruiting recent graduates offers a strategic approach to talent development. Entry-level positions can be filled at a competitive salary range, and with proper mentorship and training, these graduates are provided the opportunity to grow within your organisation. This approach allows you to cultivate talent internally, ensuring that your team is well-equipped for future challenges while effectively managing your recruitment budget.
Good Working Habits & Latest Practices: University graduates often bring good working habits developed through their academic learning. They are trained to follow best practices in the industry, adhere to the latest engineering methodologies, and comply with safety protocols. Unlike some more experienced engineers who may have picked up bad habits, university graduates tend to avoid cutting corners. Their adherence to these high standards makes them a good influence and ensures they can quickly adapt to and align with your company’s standards and expectations. These well-established habits can be valuable assets, significantly reducing the need for extensive training and guidance.
Deciding between hiring a university graduate or a graduate apprentice depends on your company’s specific needs and values. University graduates bring cutting-edge knowledge, fresh perspectives, and technological fluency, while graduate apprentices offer invaluable real-life experience, practical skills, and a strong work ethic. Both paths have their strengths, and the best choice will vary depending on your organisational goals and the specific role you are looking to fill. Ultimately, a balanced approach, integrating both types of graduates into your workforce, would be the most effective strategy for sustained success and innovation.
If you’re looking to infuse your team with fresh talent, whether it’s innovative university graduates or experienced apprentice graduates, we’re here to help. Get in touch with us today to find the perfect candidates for your organisation’s needs.
< back to other articles
